
JW Marriott Marco Island Beach Resort
Best for families and groups who want multiple pools, on-site watersports, and a long private Gulf beach.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
JW Marriott Marco Island Beach Resort is a large Gulf-front resort on Marco Island with multiple pools, a full-scale spa, and many dining options—good for families, groups, and travelers who want a full-service beach resort. Inn on Fifth is a well-known 4-star boutique hotel on Naples’ Fifth Avenue for travelers who prefer walkable downtown dining, shopping, and a compact spa hotel rather than a beachfront mega-resort.
Updated · about 17–18 miles (≈27–29 km) apart

Best for families and groups who want multiple pools, on-site watersports, and a long private Gulf beach.

Best for travelers who want walkable access to Fifth Avenue South restaurants, shops, and a compact downtown hotel with spa services.
When JW Marriott Marco Island Beach Resort wins: choose JW Marriott Marco Island if you want a big beachfront resort experience—multiple pools (including a waterslide and an adults-only enclave), more on-site restaurants and bars, a large Spa by JW, and extensive meeting or event spaces.
When Inn on Fifth wins: pick Inn on Fifth if your priority is being steps from Fifth Avenue South’s dining and shopping, staying in a smaller boutique property with a full-service spa and an intimate downtown vibe.
Bottom line: JW Marriott Marco Island is the better fit for beach-first, activity-heavy stays and larger groups; Inn on Fifth is the smarter choice for downtown convenience, walkability, and a boutique hotel feel.
| Category | JW Marriott Marco Island Beach Resort | Inn on Fifth |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Large Gulf-front resort with family and group programming | Compact 4-star boutique hotel on Naples’ Fifth Avenue |
| Location | Private Gulf-front beach on Marco Island (South Collier Blvd) | Downtown Naples on 5th Avenue South (699 5th Ave S) |
| Distance between properties | about 17–18 miles (≈27–29 km) to Inn on Fifth | |
| Size | Large resort (roughly 700–800 rooms across multiple towers; extensive meeting space) | Smaller hotel (119 guestrooms) |
| Ages / family policy | All-ages resort with kids’ club, children’s pool and a 21+ adults-only enclave (Paradise by Sirene) | All-ages property (not adults-only); family-friendly features not the primary focus |
| Pools & water access | Multiple outdoor pools (3–4 reported), waterslide, private Gulf beach and beach umbrellas | One outdoor pool and a hot tub; complimentary beach shuttle to Naples Beach |
| Beach | Private Gulf-front beach (three miles of private beachfront) | Not beachfront — offers free beach shuttle to Naples Beach |
| Restaurants & bars | About 12 on-site restaurants and bars (steakhouse, beachfront seafood, tiki bar, gastropub, café, etc.) | One on-site restaurant and bar; room service during limited hours |
| Spa & wellness | Spa by JW — a stand-alone 24,000 sq ft Balinese-style spa with treatments and spa pool | Full-service spa with massages, facials and treatment rooms |
| Known for | Beach activities, family-friendly pools, extensive dining and large event space | Walkable Fifth Avenue South location, boutique feel, terrace/rooftop and downtown dining |
JW Marriott Marco Island sits directly on Marco Island’s Gulf frontage with private beach access.
A stay here centers on beach access and resort-based activities rather than walkable town dining.
Inn on Fifth is positioned on Naples’ Fifth Avenue, steps from shops and restaurants.
Stay at Inn on Fifth if you want walkable downtown amenities and an easy link to Naples’ Fifth Avenue scene.
JW Marriott Marco Island offers many room types across several towers, including an adults-only enclave.
Expect a broad selection of room styles and family-friendly options, plus a dedicated adults-only product.
Inn on Fifth has 119 guestrooms with a mix of city, plaza, pool and 5th Avenue views plus suites.
Choose Inn on Fifth for compact, well-located rooms near shops and restaurants rather than resort-scale variety.
JW Marriott Marco Island has an extensive set of dining and bar options across the resort.
Great choice if you want a wide range of on-site meal and nightlife options without leaving the resort.
Inn on Fifth concentrates on its single on-site restaurant and downtown dining nearby.
Inn on Fifth relies on its superb location for dining variety—walk to dozens of independent restaurants.
Pools and beach are central features at JW Marriott Marco Island, including family and adults-only options.
Best for travelers who want on-site pool variety plus dedicated private beach access.
Inn on Fifth has a single outdoor pool, a hot tub, and provides a complimentary beach shuttle.
A compact pool offering that pairs with easy shuttle access to Naples Beach when you want sand and surf.
The resort has a large Spa by JW and multiple evening venues for families and adults.
Good for guests who want a full-service spa plus casual and lively nighttime options on-site.
Inn on Fifth offers a full-service spa and a quieter downtown evening scene.
Pick Inn on Fifth for a quieter spa-focused stay with easy access to downtown Naples nightlife.

Multiple pools (including a waterslide and adults-only rooftop pool) plus private Gulf-front beach.

Steps from Fifth Avenue South restaurants, boutiques and Cambier Park.

Extensive meeting and event spaces—with large ballrooms and flexible conference rooms across the resort.

Boutique scale, a full-service spa, and immediate access to downtown Naples make it ideal for short city-focused stays.
JW Marriott Marco Island is better for families—children’s club, kids’ pool and a waterslide are all on site.
Inn on Fifth—it sits on Fifth Avenue South within easy walking distance of many restaurants, cafés and shops.
JW Marriott Marco Island has private Gulf-front beach access on property. Inn on Fifth is not beachfront but provides a complimentary beach shuttle to Naples Beach.
JW Marriott Marco Island has Spa by JW, a stand-alone 24,000 sq ft Balinese-style spa. Inn on Fifth offers a full-service spa but on a smaller scale.
Explore how JW Marriott Marco Island Beach Resort stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·